===================================
Recommended Home Theater Projectors
===================================
"Highly Recommended"
SANYO PLC-XP21N
The Sanyo PLC-XP21N is at this
writing (3/01) one of the strongest home theater performers on the market for under
$10,000. Though its official MSRP at release was $11,995, street prices are currently around
$7,000.
Brightness. The XP21N is rated at 2500 ANSI lumens. After video calibration
we measured our review sample at 1850. So it is a bright projector that can fill a very large
screen. The use of a screen not exceeding 1.0 gain is recommended (the Stewart Grayhawk
is an ideal match as discussed further below.)
Contrast ratio. The XP21N has a contrast rating of 700:1 which is a
breakthrough achievement in LCD technology. One of the major benefits of the competing
DLP technology has always been a relatively high contrast ratio as compared to LCD
products. DLP was in the past able to produce deeper black levels and better color
saturation due to contrast ratios in the range of 500:1 or 600:1, compared to LCD products
that were in the range of 200:1 to 400:1. However, the XP21N's 700:1 contrast ratio sets a
new performance benchmark for LCD systems and effectively changes the competitive
dynamics between LCD and DLP. Very few DLP projectors on the market can match this
performance although a few are now rated at 800:1 (most notably the NEC LT150 discussed
herein).
Micro Lens Array. The XP21N is an XGA-resolution LCD projector with native
1024 x 768 LCD panels. An important feature of the XP21N is that it has Micro Lens Array
(MLA). This increases the fill factor on the LCD panels and reduces the visibility of the pixel
grid to almost zero. For home theater, the importance of invisible or nearly invisible pixels
on products in this price range is paramount. It is the presence of MLA on the XP21N that
elevates it to "highly recommended" status above the less expensive PLC-XP18N, which is
essentially the same machine without MLA.
Thus with one impressive stroke, the two primary competitive strengths of DLP
technology—high contrast and no pixelation—have been impressively addressed in this
unique new Sanyo offering. This product should cause those who believe that DLP is the
only good solution for home theater to stop and rethink the matter.
Color.One of the traditional strengths of LCD systems is the ability to control
red, green, and blue channels independently so that relatively accurate color balances can
be achieved. The XP21N's color is as beautiful and natural as any that we've seen in digital
projectors. And the high contrast ratio gives colors a richness and subtlety that surpasses
anything in its price range.
HDTV and EDTV. This product is HDTV and EDTV (480p) compatible. The use
of a component-progressive scan (480p) DVD player for DVDs is strongly recommended.
The XP21N has both 4:3 and 16:9 display options, but the widescreen option works only for
a 480p signal. A component 480i signal must be displayed in 4:3.
Connectivity. The connection panel offers a variety of inputs including two
15-pin VGA ports, a set of three RCA jacks for component video input, one S-video, and one
composite video jack.
Fan noise. Fan noise is low to moderate. With an audible noise rating of 39
dB, the XP21N is not whisper quiet. However, it is low in pitch. Most users will have no
problem with it since surround sound audio will mask it on all but the quietest of scenes.
But for those that are particularly sensitive to the presence of any fan noise whatsoever,
properly designed sound damping enclosures will mitigate the problem.
Throw distance. Throw distance to screen size is about average for projectors
in this class. A 100" 4:3 diagonal image can be thrown from as little as 12 feet. For
installation planning purposes, keep in mind that the exhaust is out the rear of the
projector, and that the manual calls for a 3-foot clearance between the rear of the projector
and the back wall. So do not think about putting the XP21N on a bookshelf or ceiling-
mounting it very close to a back wall.
Lamp life. Lamp life is 2000 hours and you can expect to pay at least $400
for replacements. This is not atypical for the category.
Screens. During our test of the XP21N we used both a Da-lite 1.3 gain
CinemaVision and the new Stewart Grayhawk. The Grayhawk, currently rated at 0.95 gain, is
strongly recommended for use with the XP21N. The amount of light reflected from the
Grayhawk as compared to the Da-lite is lower by about 30%.
But more importantly, the Stewart Grayhawk has the optical property of further
increasing contrast, especially when there is low indirect lighting in the room or when light
from the screen is being reflected from white or light-colored walls and furnishings in the
viewing room. The most beautiful performance of the XP21N and Grayhawk combination
occurred when low indirect ambient lighting was introduced into the viewing space. The
screen image, which already sparkled, tended to take on an even richer and more well-
integrated appearance.
The Grayhawk is a premium quality product and is priced accordingly. But those who
are opting for the XP21N are serious about top performing video. After seeing it on the
Grayhawk, we wouldn't want to watch the XP21N on anything else. If you can fit one into
your budget, we encourage you to do so.
Conclusion. The Sanyo PLC-XP21N is visually stunning. It is truly unique in
that it combines the beauty of LCD color with an astounding 700:1 contrast ratio, and tops
it off with virtually pixel-free projection. The day we had to pack up our review unit and ship
it back was a sad one indeed. We are pleased to recommend it highly as among the finest
price/performing projectors for home theater ever brought to market.