The Amazing SharpVision XV-Z9000U
Evan Powell, ProjectorCentral, November 2, 2001
http://www.projectorcentral.com
Sharp has taken a major step forward in digital projection price/performance
with the release of the Sharpvision XV-
Z9000U. It is a breakthrough product that sets a new benchmark for video
quality at the $10,000 price point. Featuring the industry's first 16:9 widescreen format DLP
chip, a sparkling 1100:1 contrast ratio, and extremely precise onboard scaling, the Z9000 is
capable of delivering astounding film-like video images with virtual CRT quality.
The Z9000 is perhaps the first digital projector we've ever seen that is worth every
penny of its full retail price (technically $10,995 in the press release, but effectively $9,999
as it is being advertised by Sharp's authorized dealers). That is a good thing because Sharp,
like a number of other vendors who sell to the high-end home theater market, is
distributing the Z9000 through a limited number of dealers and specialty retailers. So don't
expect much discounting from the authorized resellers. (more on this below).
Product Overview
At the heart of the Z9000 is Texas Instrument's 16:9 widescreen 1280x720
DLP chip and a 5x speed color wheel, illuminated by a 250-watt lamp. The projector is rated
at 800 ANSI lumens with an 1100:1 full on/off contrast ratio.
The Z9000 is obviously designed for ceiling-mounted home theater applications. In
other words, despite the fact that you can hook your laptop to it, this is not a projector that
can do double duty as a mobile presentation unit. At 21 lbs and with a 19"x18" footprint, it
is relatively large and heavy as digital projectors go. That is great for stifling fan noise (the
projector is almost silent in operation) but lousy for shlepping around town. So if you are
looking for a multi-purpose machine, look elsewhere.
The Z9000 will accept 1080i, 720p, 480p, 480i, component, S-video, and composite
video. It will take computer signals up to SXGA (1280x1024). The inputs on the Z9000
include two sets of 5 RCA jacks for component/RGB, one 15-pin Dsub for data input only,
one composite video RCA, one S-video, an RS-232 serial port and a wired remote
minijack.
This projector has all of the image adjustment controls the videophile would want for
optimization of the picture including gamma correction, color temperature adjustment, and
independent controls for red, green, and blue contrast and brightness. A variety of aspect
ratios can be accommodated.
The Z9000 offers a remarkably clean digital keystone adjustment capability. On most
digital projectors, digital keystone adjustments introduce compression artifacts that render
the video image fuzzy an often almost unwatchable. Thus we routinely suggest that you
leave the keystone adjustment set to zero and forget about it. Though we would offer this
advice for the Z9000 as well, the image that it produced with keystone adjustments active
was largely free of compression artifacts.
Performance
The first remarkable thing about the Z9000 was that it was reasonably close to being
optimally calibrated right out of the box. This is unique in our experience. With all controls
set to factory pre-set the Z9000 produced a satisfying image with excellent color balance,
black level, and contrast. This should help sales a great deal since it is being sold by
dealers/retailers who have demo rooms, but who often do not have the expertise in house
to calibrate projectors to optimum performance.
Nevertheless, with a few relatively small adjustments, the picture quality can be
improved another notch. If you are going to invest in a product of this quality, we strongly
urge you to pick up a copy of the DVD calibration disc The AVIA Guide to Home
Theater. It has a variety of test patterns and instructions to help you get your video
system tweaked up to a higher level of performance than you could achieve by eyeballing
it.
The contrast performance of the Z9000 is exceptional. Its 1100:1 contrast rating is in
rarified atmosphere in the world of digital projectors. Does this high rating translate to real
performance on the screen you ask? All we can say is this: if you didn't know you were
looking at a digital image, you'd probably assume you were viewing a fine CRT system.
Another remarkable feature of the Z9000 is its internal scaling, which is simply
sensational--the best we've yet seen on a digital projector. And with the high resolution DLP
chip, pixels are invisible. The combination of virtually artifact-free scaling and the
invisibility of the pixels produced a smooth, seamless, well-integrated image that, again,
one usually associates with high performance CRTs.
It goes without saying that the Z9000's widescreen 1280x720 format gives it a decided
edge in HDTV resolution over competing projectors with standard 1024x768 DLP chips. In
particular, ABC's 720p format is displayed in native resolution on the Z9000 for a picture
that is unbeatable.
The Z9000 is, as noted above, a DLP machine. And some people have been sensitive to
an artifact known as the DLP "rainbow" effect that can occur along the edge of objects in
motion. The accelerated rotation of the 5x speed color wheel on the Z9000 is designed
specifically to reduce the errors in rapid motion display that cause the rainbow effect. In
practical terms, very few people will be able to detect any rainbow effect at all on this
product. For those few that may be able to, it is not nearly as prevalent or obvious as it may
have been on earlier generation machines.
In another review we stated that a $10,000 projector should have DVI input. The Z9000
does not. In theory the benefit of DVI is that it eliminates the need for D/A conversions and
the jitter that is often produced by them. However, the stability of the Z9000's picture with
high quality analog inputs is so good that you won't miss DVI for a minute. On this machine,
the lack of DVI is a non-issue as long as you have high quality analog sources.
Sources make the difference
There is some bads news here, if you want to think of it that way. The bad news is that
a projector that has the resolution power of the Z9000 demands top quality sources to
produce a top quality image. Garbage in, garbage out was never more obviously true than it
is on this projector. On lesser machines, scaling inaccuracies, resolution limitations, and
pixelation serve to mask some of the deficiencies in television signals, DVD disc transfers,
and DVD players themselves.
On the Z9000 the deficiencies of your sources will be glaringly obvious to you. Do not
attempt to drive the Z9000 with a cheap DVD player and expect the projector to overcome
the defects of the source. It won't, just like a Ferrari won't perform well on cheap gasoline.
So if you are thinking of going with a Z9000, think also in terms of upgrading that old DVD
player to something in the class of the Denon DVD-2800 or better.
Along this same line of thinking, contrary to popular belief "DVD" is not always
synonymous with good picture quality. There is in fact a huge variation in the quality of DVD
transfers, from the pristine to the virtually unwatchable. You won't notice this on a 27"
television, but once you go to a Z9000 on a 100" screen, the wide variations in DVD disc
quality will become painfully obvious. Therefore, you might want to get familiar with a
publication called Widescreen Review. They do a terrific job of rating the video and audio quality of every DVD on the
market. As distasteful as it sounds, the quality of a DVD's transfer may become an
important criterion to you as you select your viewing material. If it does, Widescreen Review
can help you sort them all out.
Buying the Z9000
Well. Here is the situation. Sharp is distributing the Z9000 through a select number of
authorized dealers/retailers. Typically these dealers/retailers have specifically assigned
geographical territories in which they must conduct business. They cannot sell outside their
territories, on the Internet or otherwise.
This distribution strategy has produced a gray market in the Z9000. The way it works is
unauthorized dealers buy from authorized dealers and resell to consumers at discounted
prices. So at this time you can find the Z9000 available on the gray market, via the Internet,
at prices about $2,000 below what the authorized dealers are selling it for.
There is a catch here however—the product you get from the gray market dealers does
not come with a valid Sharp factory warranty. Depending upon how reputable the gray
market dealer is, he may attempt to deceive you, or he may be up front about the lack of a
Sharp warranty. He may offer his own services to back up the product in lieu of a Sharp
warranty.
Buying through the gray market also increases the risk that the product you get will be
damaged stock, demo stock, used equipment being sold as new, or sometimes even
imported from other markets where compatibility might be an issue. Other than to alert you
to the possible risks, we cannot advise you further in this regard.
ProjectorCentral's position is this: we do not knowingly allow unauthorized dealers to
advertise or participate in any sale or bid activity on our site. We do this to reduce the risk
that buyers will be victimized by unethical gray market tactics. We assume that the
manufacturer has chosen its authorized dealers based on their viability, reputation, and
ability to handle after sales service and support. Therefore, since Sharp currently prohibits
their authorized Z9000 dealers from selling on the Internet, this model has been removed
from the Get Bids! system. So please do not request bids on this product.
At this time the only way to buy a Sharpvision XV-Z9000 with a valid Sharp warranty in
accordance with Sharp's distribution policies is to buy from a dealer authorized to sell you
the product in your particular location. To find out who that dealer is, click "Dealers" on
ProjectorCentral's left navigation bar, select "SharpVision" as the brand and enter your
location. If there is no SharpVision dealer listed in your area, please call Sharp at 877-388-
SHARP for further assistance.