SMART LightRaise 40wi
- Shows detail well on data screens.
- Supports a dual pen mode (but comes with only one pen).
- Interactive mode drops brightness by only 16%.
- Pen doesn't have to touch screen
- 3D Ready
- Ranked #6 for:
- Video image quality
- Ranked #5 for:
- Data Image Quality
- Interactive Features
Data image quality. Data image quality for the BenQ MW860USTi (hereafter, "MW860" for easier reading) is best described as usable but far from impressive. Very much on the plus side, it holds detail better than any other 1280x800 projector in this group, with black on white text easily readable at 7 points and white on black text easily readable at 8 points. In addition, rainbow artifacts are far fewer, more fleeting, and less obvious than with the other DLP projectors, so that even if you see these artifacts easily you're not likely to be bothered by them.
Unfortunately, the overall data image quality is dragged down by colors that are fully saturated but dull and dark (in terms of a hue-saturation-brightness color model) to the point of being muddy. All the DLP models we looked at share this problem to some extent, but it was most extreme with the MW860.
Interactive features. Like all projectors with TI's DLP-based interactive technology, the MW860 doesn't need calibration and doesn't need the pen touching the screen. One minor issue I saw was a slight lag between moving the pen and seeing the result on screen, whether I was touching or not. It's not hard to get used to, but it's not as comfortable, or as immediately natural, as using a pen with no lag at all.
Also worth mention is that the MW860 offers a dual pen mode, so two people can annotate the image at the same time. The second pen is a $99 option, however, and BenQ didn't provide one for testing, so we have no way to know if it works as well as the Epson 485Wi's dual pen mode.
Interactive software support. BenQ gears its interactive software primarily towards Windows. The projector comes with Windows annotation software only, it fully supports Windows 8, and it doesn't need a Windows driver. BenQ says that it doesn't need a Mac driver either, but older Macs may need a patch, which is on the projector's installation disc. You'll have to get Mac annotation software elsewhere.
Video image quality. If you need a projector for video, the MW860 is the wrong choice. When we looked at video from all six projectors in this shootout side by side in both their brightest modes with reasonable color quality and their best color modes, it was immediately obvious in both cases that the MW860 was the least watchable. With either preset, its colors tend to be muddy. There's also a slight overscan that we couldn't find any way to turn off, so the projector loses some of the image along each edge. Video with the MW860 is best limited to short clips if you use it at all.
Installation and maintenance. The MW860 ties for fourth place with the Dell S500wi for ease of installation. It also ties for fourth place with the Sony SW535C for ease of maintenance. For installation, it offers the convenience of separate adjustments for roll, pitch, and yaw, but no way to adjust the horizontal or vertical position of the image. For maintenance, it offers a lamp life of 2500 hours in standard mode and 4000 hours in Eco mode, but replacing the lamp requires removing and reinstalling three screws.
Audio. The MW860's two 10-watt stereo speakers offer reasonably good quality audio, but with volume suitable only for a small room.
Brightness. In its brightest mode, the MW860 came out to 79% of its rating, or 2357 lumens, with other presets ranging as low as 1326 lumens. Unlike most interactive projectors, it offers only one interactive mode, which we measured at 1989 lumens, or about 84% of its brightest mode. As with all the DLP projectors in this overview, its color brightness is significantly lower, at 496 lumens in its brightest mode. Among other issues, that means that color images won't be as bright as with LCD projectors with similar ANSI lumen measurements.
Connections. The back panel on the MW860 offers a fairly typical set of connectors:
- 1 HDMI
- 2 VGA IN (for RGB or component)
- 1 S-video
- 1 RCA composite
- 2 USB A
- 1 VGA OUT (monitor loop-through)
- 1 USB B
- 1 mini USB B
- 1 LAN (for network control)
- 1 Stereo mini plug
- 1 RCA stereo IN
- 1 Microphone input
- 1 Stereo mini plug OUT
- 1 RS-232
The BenQ MW860USTi's ability to hold details well can easily trump the issues with color for anyone who needs to show detailed images or relatively small text. It also shows rainbow artifacts less often than the other DLP projectors we compared it with, while still offering the strengths of TI's approach to interactivity. There's no calibration needed, no need to touch the screen, and you even get 3D-support, although you can't use 3D and interactive modes at the same time. Factor in the relatively low price, and there's enough here to make the BenQ MW860USTi a more than reasonable choice for the right application.