Samsung SP-F10M XGA 3LCD Projector
Projector Central Highly Recommended Award

Highly Recommended Award

Our Highly Recommended designation is earned by products offering extraordinary value or performance in their price class.

  • Performance
  • 5
  • Features
  • Ease of Use
  • Value
Price
$1,299 MSRP Discontinued

The new Samsung F10M is an eagerly anticipated presentation projector combining traditional LCD-based projection technology with LED illumination. The result is a 1,000-lumen XGA projector with a 30,000 hour estimated lamp life--a notable accomplishment. The 1,000 lumen mark makes the F10M the brightest LED-driven projector yet released, bar none. What's even more notable is that the F10M has an MSRP of only $1,099. Combined with a three-year warranty and a solid feature set, the F10M is perfect for small to medium conference rooms.

Advantages

Light output. The main reason that LED projectors are not more widespread is the problem of light output. LEDs thus far have not been able to match the performance of traditional metal-halide lamps in terms of sheer light output, which is why these traditional lamps still see use despite their relatively short lives.

The F10M is a step in the right direction, for certain. Rated at 1,000 ANSI lumens, our test sample measured 837 lumens using the Bright image preset, which was the maximum measured on this unit. In a conference room, this is a good amount of light for a 60" to 80" diagonal image with the lights dimmed or a 50" diagonal with all room lighting at its maximum. Compared to many other LED projectors, this is an incredible improvement.

Bright mode, as one might imagine, is the ideal choice for simple, high-contrast documents that need to be displayed big and bright. If your presentation involves material that is better served by a more subtle treatment, the F10M's other image presets can provide that. Dynamic, the default, measured 745 lumens. Its black level is deeper than that of Bright, though not by much; it is an incremental improvement that will make documents look subtly more colorful and will emphasize shadow detail slightly. The F10M has several other presets, each suited for a different application. At 684 lumens, Presentation is a step down in brightness from Bright, but it has a cooler color temperature, better black level, and more open mid-tones. Standard mode continues this trend at 679 lumens. Movie mode has superior color saturation and shadow detail, as well as the best contrast to be had from the projector in any operating mode. It measured 667 lumens.

Brightness uniformity. The difference between the brightest and dimmest areas of a pure white test image was quite small, and overall the F10M had a measured brightness uniformity of 85%. A smooth, evenly-illuminated image is crucial when it comes to photography and video, and even text documents look better when the "sheet of paper" on screen is not noticeably dimmer in one corner.

Contrast. Compared to other LCD projectors, the F10M has a very wide dynamic range. Black level is deep for a projector in this class, partially thanks to the use of LEDs instead of a traditional lamp. Light emitting diodes are far more variable and have much faster response times than traditional lamps do, so their output can be changed whenever necessary. And while the F10M is not a video projector, it does include a "dynamic contrast" feature that functions like an auto iris would--except it is entirely digital. Its effect on a image of a starry sky is impressive and immediately visible.

 

Color. While some data projectors struggle with color balance, the F10M has all of the accuracy and saturation one could ask for. Photographs and data graphics appear vibrant and well-saturated, and the "warm1" color preset used in Movie mode is free of any significant bias or tint. The Bright and Presentation presets have a slight green and blue tint, respectively, as one would expect from modes designed for ambient light use. However these tints are not as prominent or distracting as one might expect given experience with the competition. In some instances, the blue cast of Presentation might even be desirable, inasmuch as the blue will help to cancel out some of the yellow cast imbued by room lighting.

LED Engine. LEDs, unlike traditional lamps, last for a very long time; in the case of the F10M, estimated lamp life is 30,000 hours. If you are anything like me, you have trouble wrapping your head around big numbers, so: you can use this projector for four hours at a stretch every single day, starting today, and the lamp will not expire until early April of 2030 - over twenty years from now.

What makes this projector so different from others is its LED-powered LCD light engine, the first of its kind (previous LED-based projectors have used LCOS or DLP engines). The most obvious effect of the use of LCDs is increased brightness. While 2,000 lumen LED-powered projectors are still a ways off, the F10M's 1,000 lumens are already a huge step in the right direction. It has the highest light output of any projector solely using LEDs for illumination. Considering this fact, its rock-bottom price is impressive indeed.

Picture quality. Tech details aside, the F10M looks great. Its bright, high-contrast image is punchy enough for film and video and more than enough for simple text documents and Powerpoint slideshows. The focus mechanism is precise and crisp, and on top of that edge-to-edge sharpness is consistent, so the resultant image is high in detail and looks wonderful. The long and short of it is that the F10M has a smooth, consistent, bright, colorful image with above average contrast for a data projector. To top it all off, the lamp will last for years and years. There is not much more one could reasonably ask of a sub-$1100 data projector.

Video Performance. The F10M is built with the business presentation market in mind, but as it is a reasonably bright LED projector some people will want to know how it fares for video and film. Luckily for them, the answer is "quite well." The F10M has an HDMI port, so you can connect your Blu-ray player or HTPC without the need for a breakout cable. It is only 1024x768 (or XGA) resolution, so high-definition movies will need to be compressed. The F10M does an admirable job of re-processing 1280x720 and 1920x1080 signals to fit its native 1024x768 pixel matrix without introducing compression artifacts. Since it is a 4:3 projector, widescreen movies will leave black bars at the top and bottom of the image; the image itself will be either 1024x576 for 16:9 or 1024x428 for cinemascope.

As far as the image itself, dynamic range is very good, as previously mentioned, compared to other data projectors. What's more, the F10M includes a "dynamic contrast" function which acts like an iris, stopping down to lower black levels in low-illumination scenes. Color is vibrant and mostly accurate, especially using the Movie preset. Even compressed, Blu-ray movies retain much of their sharpness and detail clarity. This is not to say that the F10M is the equal of a home cinema projector when it comes to home cinema; it isn't. It lacks somewhat in the areas of dynamic range and most importantly resolution. An XGA projector will never appear as clear and sharp as a 1080p projector, even when it is as capable as the F10M when it comes to video. If you're looking for a gaming an entertainment projector, the F10M might just fit the bill; however, if you want a [i]home theater[/i] projector and just cannot wait to get your hands on an LED model, it would be best if you were to suppress your excitement and wait a little longer.

Connectivity. In addition to the standard VGA, S-Video, and Composite connections, the F10M also has an HDMI port for all of your high-quality video or data transmission needs. There's also an RJ45 network jack, so the F10M can be tied into the organization's internal network and monitored remotely. Your IT department will appreciate the help.

Audible noise. The F10M has low audible noise, which is somewhat surprising. LEDs are famous for putting out a lot of heat, so LED projectors are generally either small and not very bright (pico and pocket projectors) or very large and loud (home theater projectors). As the first of its kind, the F10M sets the standard by which future products will be judged, and that bar has been set very high. In Eco mode the fan is even quieter, so no matter how small your conference space you will not find yourself annoying the audience with excessive fan noise.

7W Speaker. The F10M has a seven-watt speaker, which is a good size for small conference rooms and not much else. Since there is only one speaker there is no stereo support, and cranking the volume too high results in a touch of tinny, rattly distortion. For any serious music listening or movie watching, an external set of speakers would be ideal, but the onboard equipment is certainly better than the usual anemic one-watt speakers seen far too often on data projectors.

Limitations

Placement flexibility. The F10M has a 1.2:1 manual focus lens, which is more or less standard in XGA data projectors. What is unusual is its throw angle offset, which does not follow the typical pattern set by similar competing projectors. Most conference room projectors have a lens that places the image either entirely above the lens centerline or such that the bottom edge is flush with the lens centerline. The F10M instead places roughly 15% of the image below the lens centerline. If you want to avoid keystone correction, you will either need to offset the screen relative to your conference room table or use a drop tube in your ceiling mount. This offset does open up the possibility of a rear shelf mount, which is not often possible with data projectors because of the lack of lens shift. Of course, with a relatively limited zoom range and no lens shift, such an installation would need to be meticulously planned--there is little room for error.

Weight. The F10M is heavy for a conference room projector at just over nine pounds. In the age of netbooks and smartphones, this more or less relegates the F10M to fixed installation use only, since carrying a nine-pound bag of projector does not constitute portability anymore. In a pinch, it is certainly svelte enough to fit in a bag; external dimensions are only 3.6" tall by 9.1" deep by 11.7" wide. If your primary use for the projector is as a traveling unit, though, you may want to pick a lighter, smaller alternative.

Shared audio input. Usually, a projector with a relatively beefy onboard speaker like the F10M will have separate audio inputs for each video input, allowing an installation where each device has a discrete set of connections. The F10M has a shared audio input--two RCA jacks for stereo input. HDMI can still carry audio, of course, but VGA, DVI (via HDMI adapter), S-Video, and Composite must all share a single audio input. If you have a lot of devices to connect simultaneously, such as an office media room, you may wish to consider adding an audio switching device into the loop.

Conclusion

The Samsung F10M is something of a revolutionary projector, though one might not think that by looking at it. Outwardly, it looks like just another me-too XGA business presentation machine, albeit with some nice features like a decent speaker and RJ45 networking. Instead, it is the brightest pure LED driven projector to hit the market thus far, and it comes at a bargain price. Does the F10M cost more than other, similar XGA LCD projectors? Yes, of course. The trade-off, though, is that you will never need to replace the lamp in the F10M. While that might not seem important now, in several years when the projector is still going strong you will look back on your initial purchase and smile.

For more detailed specifications and connections, check out our Samsung SP-F10M projector page.

Comments (9) Post a Comment
John Meyer Posted Oct 8, 2010 4:28 PM PST
When I wrap my head around those led lifespan numbers I get something different.

4 hours a day x 365 days = 1460 hours per year.

If the life is 30,000 hours this equals 20.5 years.

Certainly generous by todays projector standards.

Cheers, John Meyer
Nic Lavroff Posted Oct 8, 2010 4:35 PM PST
Bill:

You may want to check your math on the lamp life. Running the projector four hours a day comes to approximately 1500 hours per year. With a 30,000 hour lamp life, this amounts to about 20 years, well beyond its technological obsolescence.
Paul Vail Posted Oct 8, 2010 6:20 PM PST
Bill, your math with big numbers isn't dead on this time! ;o)

30,000 hours - if you turn it on today, and use it 24 hours a day, it will run for about 3.4 years. The article states that if it is on 4 hours a day it will last that long.

Just wanted to point out the typo/math mistake because if you stick with 4 hours of use a day, then the Samsung will last for about TWENTY years! That's a phenomenal number and is what I call the epic school projector. Install it in a classroom, and by the time it dies, the school should be ready for a new projector in their budget for sure.

Heck, compare to a $700 projector which will likely need a new lamp every 1-2 years, and all the labor to install those lamps, within a couple of years, even the cheapest projector breaks even for a school system. At the second lamp replacement, the school is losing money.

Now all we need from Samsung is a 720p and a 1080p version of the exact same thing!
Hyp3r Posted Oct 9, 2010 2:33 AM PST
Lamp life of 3,5 years is correct with 24 hours/day of use. I Think the article miss a 2 before the 4 :-)
Bill Livolsi Posted Oct 9, 2010 12:47 PM PST
Nic and John:

You are, of course, correct. The three-and-a-half-years figure is how long the lamp would last (in theory) if it were run constantly, twenty-four hours a day. Since the projector is not meant to be used in this way, and since very few people would find that a useful figure, I decided to change the reference. As you can see, the two were mixed together at some point.

I have corrected the reference in the article and I thank you both for letting us know.
Marcos Augusto Posted Oct 10, 2010 4:54 PM PST
Considering that it uses 3 LCD panels i wonder how good was the panel alignment; Were test images used showing horizontal/vertical lines and how did R/G/B colors for each panel superimpose on one another onscreen ? I wish you still had the LG HX-300G at hand to do a comparison shoot-out between it and the Samsung F10M...
John Meyer Posted Oct 13, 2010 2:52 PM PST
Is the shadow detail and contrast performance of the F10M projector superior to that of similarly spec'd lamp projectors given the speed of the LEDs?

Asked another way.

Is it possible to say that LEDs have an inherent advantage over lamp projectors due to the speed of the LEDs which is not captured by our current test methods?

Cheers, John Meyer
wayne turner Posted Jan 18, 2011 1:14 PM PST
I built a home made movie projector with a 3M 1750 series and a saka wide screen 7inch lcd tv/monitor,the vid and pics of build are on facebook under my name with vincent in the middle,uk, nwo just been doing some research and to see what this baby can do well,guess what my next one is been powered by ? yes a 1000 lumen output home made L.E.D. engine,most likely powered inline with lcd tv power supply,the overhead pro build was too bright in places,yet it gave a good sharp-ish picture,pay 1000 u.s. dollars or whatnot in pounds,no sir eeeee,not when you can build one,have fun in doing,and be proud you've saved a packet :) good design mind !!!
mapromedia Posted Mar 16, 2012 8:55 PM PST
In most situations the lamp change out on traditional projector is ten minutes. I've went through 4 lamps in the lifetime of an Epson (going on ten years). Average cost of 150 a lamp. It may be more cost effective to just start swapping out new projectors on a more regular basis.

How much is an LED replacement? Based on the cost of household led lamps at Home Depot the cost is 5 to 6 times the normal cost for a traditional lamp. I can only imagine the cost of a 1000 lumen LED fixture for a small market like projectors.

Post a comment

 
Enter the numbers as they appear to the left